Greenaway's Active Reviewing Tips 8.1 ~ ISSN 1465-8046 A
free monthly publication from Reviewing Skills Training
ARTips 8.1 Reviewing for Fun
~ 1 ~ EDITOR: Designed to Fail?
~ 2 ~ TIPS ARTICLE: Reviewing for Fun
~ 3 ~ BOOKSHOP: Humour at No. 1
~ 4 ~ OPEN WORKSHOPS: South Africa, USA, Hong Kong, UK
~ 5 ~ About Active Reviewing Tips
Just for balance the next issue will be on the transfer of learning:
Reviewing for Results
1 ~ EDITOR: Designed to Fail?
The last issue of Active Reviewing Tips on 'Reviewing for Development' was a bit of a personal milestone as it helped me to appreciate something quite fundamental about reviewing:
''It is my belief that the experience of a review is at least as important as the experience of the event being reviewed. How can we advocate learning through experience without paying attention to the experience of learning?''
I have since had the opportunity of exploring this theme in my training workshops. Which has led to another 'aha!' moment. Which is that many training exercises do not provide satisfying experiences in the first place. In fact some exercises are carefully designed to generate failure!
This happens when the exercise designer wants participants to learn from their mistakes. But you can't always 'blame' the designer for miserable experiences. Sometimes these arise from a poor choice of exercise such as when 10 people are given a task that needs only 5 people, resulting in pointless redundancy and not a lot of learning.
Just imagine what happens if participants experience redundancy in a training exercise followed by boredom in a review. Or imagine what happens if they experience failure in an exercise then embarrassment in a review. Maybe you don't need to imagine this. Maybe you have already witnessed or experienced this yourself?
As a facilitator you probably have more direct influence over the experience of reviewing than you do over the experience of the exercise being reviewed. This is certainly true if your way of working is that you set up independent exercises and follow these with facilitated reviews.
Whatever the age of the participants, I think we have some responsibility for trying to make the experience of reviewing a satisfying one - at least one that keeps well away from feelings of redundancy, boredom and embarrassment. And in some reviews we might even approach the dizzy heights of FUN! Which is the theme of the article that follows.
2 ~ TIPS ARTICLE: Reviewing
Download Reviewing for Fun (pdf version)
'Physics is Fun' is the title of a school text book that is firmly installed in my memory (the title, not the contents). The title reminds me of the Ministry of Truth slogans in George Orwell's 1984: 'War is Peace', 'Freedom is Slavery', 'Ignorance is Strength' ... 'Physics is Fun'.
I actually quite enjoyed Physics. Especially when the experiments went wrong. But even those lessons were not my idea of 'fun'. That's the trouble with fun. Everyone has their own idea of what it is - from school students on the one hand, to school text book writers on the (very distant) other.
I am not going to fall into the trap of imposing my idea of fun on others, but I do have a few tips, insights and stories that may help you bring a little more fun to reviewing.
Why bring fun to reviewing in the first place? I know that some kinds of fun are insensitive and can impede learning, but it is also true that fun and learning can make excellent partners. And that certainly includes 'learning from experience' - even if the original experience was not a bundle of laughs.
If you are a dedicated reader of Active Reviewing Tips and have an excellent memory you will recall this paragraph from the last issue:
''We can respond to the need for FUN by including playful exercises such as 'Empathy Tests' or 'Fortunately, Unfortunately' (an alternating round), or by including independent reviewing tasks that end with a performance such as a poem, a song, a replay, a dramatic presentation. Of course, the best fun just happens, but it helps if you create expectations that reviewing sessions can be both fun and serious. Better still if you avoid associating 'serious' with learning and 'fun' with energisers! Techniques like 'Turntable', 'Action Replay' or 'Gifts' tend to generate a healthy mixture of fun and serious within the same technique.''
This article takes fun a little further and points to some of the most 'fun' pages at <http://reviewing.co.uk>.
ICE BREAKERS (that review past experiences)
THE WORLD'S WORST ICE BREAKER
This reviewing exercise is primarily for training trainers. Ask people to tell stories about their worst experiences with ice breakers. Sharing such misery can be a fun way of learning about the pitfalls to look out for when using ice breakers. This reviewing exercise gives you a good opportunity to respond reassuringly to any fears and concerns that people may have about being asked to do silly things. You now have the sillyphobic vote, but there could still be some ice to break. [Warning: fun not guaranteed! On one occasion this became a humourless moan - so be quick to follow up with an acceptable ice breaker. If it is a trainer-training event, work with the group to produce a list of opposites which becomes a recipe for the perfect ice breaker - for this particular group. Which might just happen to be Brief Encounters ...]
BRIEF ENCOUNTERS (reviewing successes)
This is a reviewing exercise that allows people to have lots of brief one-to-one conversations about their successes. It is an ideal first exercise because you can start the exercise promptly and then quietly introduce latecomers into the exercise as they arrive. You can introduce different themes with other sets of questions, but for most purposes 'success' provides a good starting point. To give you the flavour, here are some of the success-searching questions:
<http://reviewing.co.uk/success/icebreaker.htm> together with stories from trainers who have used Brief Encounters.
ICE BREAKER (reviewing present experiences)
THE EXPRESSION GAME (a 'heart-on-the-sleeve' exercise) I originally devised this game as a trainer-training exercise to focus on what the learner in a 'learner-centred' process is experiencing. Not very sophisticated, but quite thought-provoking and playful. Not suitable for the very start of a course as it puts individuals on the spot and can give them too much to cope with.
It is a variation of a well known game in which there is one less chair than there are people. The chairless person stands in the middle continuously calling out their feelings (such as cool, pressured, special, excited, tired, isolated, happy) while others change seats. The person in the middle tries to sit in a recently vacated seat, which (if successful) results in another person becoming the chairless one. Variation: anyone who is looked at by the person in the middle must call out their feeling (just once) as soon as they are looked at (and ends up in the middle if they don't). Another variation: take more than one chair away so that more than one person is in the middle. It may then feel a bit less lonely in the middle - with each person asking the other: "How do you feel now?"
TELLING STORIES: TAKING TURNS TO TELL A GROUP STORY
FORTUNATELY, UNFORTUNATELY (for a balanced view)
This is one way in which a group (of any age) can tell the story about its performance. One person starts with a sentence beginning ''Fortunately ...''. The person on their left continues the story with a sentence beginning ''Unfortunately''. Passing is allowed but the over-riding rule is that sentences should alternate.
''Fortunately we allocated time for planning.''
''Unfortunately we didn't read the full brief.''
''Fortunately I noticed the mistake.''
''Unfortunately you didn't mention it at the time.''
This exercise is particularly useful for groups that are over-critical or under-critical of their own performance. This is because the alternation can help them to achieve a more balanced view. And for any group, it brings out achievements and problems that can be analysed in more detail later in the review. Warning: it can be fun.
THE STORYTELLER'S CHAIR (for recalling events and details) This is another way for a group to tell its story. One person sits in the storyteller's chair and starts giving a detailed account of what happened. If any listener thinks the storyteller has omitted any detail, they stand up and change places with the storyteller and continue until challenged - and so on. If at any point you want to speed things up, you can jump ahead in time and continue from a new starting point. People may be reluctant to sit in the chair if they feel they might get stuck there, so allow people to leave the chair whenever they want. If a memory test does not provide enough fun or challenge, then invite storytellers to tell the story as if they are an outsider e.g. a reporter, a customer, a boss, or other stakeholder.
Variation: EMAG YROMEM (telling the story backwards - and why) <http://reviewing.co.uk/stories/starters.htm#yromem>
TELLING STORIES: FROM AN INDIVIDUAL TO A GROUP
SOLO CHALLENGE (when individuals report back to the group) Immediately after the 'solo challenges', news and interest value are hot, and report backs are fresh, improvised and unrehearsed. In fact the report back session is often the highlight of the exercise. Everyone has a tale worth telling about their personalised challenge - and there is typically plenty of variety, emotion and humour in these tales. <http://reviewing.co.uk/toolkit/solo.challenge.htm>
THEATRE OF THE ABSURD (really active listening) When an individual has a story to tell, the audience's attention can wander. Not so in Theatre of the Absurd! This is real audience participation: everyone takes part in the story as it is told. The storyteller sees their story come to life in front of their eyes as they tell it. This is not a technique to be sprung upon a docile group or a new group. It works best if the group has already experienced a less challenging version of action replay and if you start with a story that lends itself to instant improvisation.
TELLING STORIES: TELLING A GROUP STORY TO A WIDER AUDIENCE
Communicating learning to a wider audience can be fun - especially if using drama-based methods. Groups respond well to such challenges if they have already experienced action replay or other active reviewing methods as part of their learning.
The wider audience will often expect entertainment with some serious messages mixed in, and with any luck this is also what the group wants to provide. If they need a structure then showing where they have come from (perhaps a journey of ups and downs) can be followed by showing how they are changing and then showing their dream future or future vision. If the drama ends in fantasy, some straight talking outside the drama (in the form of an epilogue) can provide a down to earth ending.
Another useful structure for a performance is overstatement, understatement and true statement. See:
Ways of sharing learning through presentation and performance are described on this page:
HIGH SPEED REVIEWING How to review a lot in a short time
CREATIVE THINKING ABOUT END OF COURSE REVIEWS
UNLIKELY TO BE A BUNDLE OF LAUGHS
Don't avoid reviewing because a group needs or wants fun. Just file away some of your favourite ideas from this article in that cluttered fun corner of your mind - and remember that reviewing can be fun! Don't be too surprised if your fun ideas get serious or your serious ideas turn out to be fun. Be ready to accept that the group may have a better sense of timing. And that fun follows no rules!
3 ~ BOOKSHOP: New Top Ten
- Humour at No. 1
This top ten in based on sales from the Active Learning Bookshop over the last three months.
1. Big Book of Humorous Training Games 2. Big Book of Icebreakers 3. The Big Book of Team Building Games 4. Team-building Activities for Every Group 5. The Accelerated Learning Handbook 6. The Complete Facilitator's Handbook 7. 102 Extra Training Games 8. Big Book of Business Games 9. Indoor/Outdoor Team Building Games for Trainers 10. Participatory Workshops
The quickest way to find these books is to view the Top Twenty page at <http://reviewing.co.uk/reviews/popular-books.htm> where you will find descriptions of all these books but in a different order.
Please note that the top 20 page changes over time!
4 ~ CALENDAR:
PROVIDED BY ROGER GREENAWAY
For the latest calendar see: http://reviewing.co.uk/_news.htm
ANYWHERE: Roger Greenaway The most cost-effective way of
receiving training in reviewing skills or the transfer of learning is to
get a group of people together with this common interest and get in
touch - wherever you are in the world. Enquire by phone or email.
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
Just for balance the next issue will be on the transfer of learning:
Reviewing for Results
5 ~ About Active
EDITOR: Dr. Roger Greenaway, Reviewing Skills Training
The Guide to Active Reviewing is at http://reviewing.co.uk
'One of the best training sites I've ever seen' Training Journal
COPYRIGHT: Roger Greenaway Reviewing Skills Training
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
What thoughts do you have about learning / reviewing / reflection / debriefing being fun. Is it? Should it be? Or does fun get in the way of learning? Please share your thoughts about fun.
|Each month Active Reviewing Tips brings you:|